[802SEC] Response to comments on the IEEE 802.3 PARs

["Law, David" <dlaw@HP.COM>]

Dear Colleagues,

Please find below the response to the comments received on the IEEE 802.3 PARs.

Best regards,
  David


IEEE P802.3br Interspersing Express Traffic Amendment
-----------------------------------------------------

Please find attached the responses to the comments received on IEEE P802.3br from IEEE 802.11. In addition a comment was received from Paul requesting that the IEEE 802.3 Vice Chair information be updated. Based on the above an updated PAR and 5 Criteria are attached.


IEEE P802.3bt DTE Power via MDI over 4-Pair Amendment
-----------------------------------------------------

Comment: What is the purpose of the content free "additional page" page 7 in the 5C?  delete
Response: The 5 Criteria have been updated to remove the last content free page. 

Comment: Please update the IEEE 802.3 Vice Chair information
Response: The PAR has been updated.

Based on the above an updated PAR and 5 Criteria can be found at the URL <http://www.ieee802.org/3/4PPOE/P802.3bt.pdf> and <http://www.ieee802.org/3/4PPOE/5Criteria.pdf>.


IEEE P802.3bu 1-Pair Power over Data Lines Amendment
----------------------------------------------------

Comment: Why didn't the WG specify a target power limit in the PAR or 5C? E.g., the IEEE P802.3bt 5C specified a power limit.
Response: The IEEE P802.3bp Reduced Twisted Pair Gigabit Ethernet channel, which 1-Pair Power over Data Lines intends to operate over, doesn't yet have a wire gauge defined, and it is anticipate that 802.3bu will operate over more than one channel, likely with different voltage and current capabilities. In addition the operating voltage has yet to be agreed. For all these reasons a target power limit was not specified.

Comment: Please update the IEEE 802.3 Vice Chair information
Response: The PAR has been updated.

Based on the above an updated PAR can be found at the URL <http://www.ieee802.org/3/1PPODL/Draft_P802_3bu_PAR_Detail.pdf>.

----------
This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector.  This list is maintained by Listserv.

Attachment: 11-13-1381-00-0000-802-11-review-DMLT_answers20131113.pdf
Description: 11-13-1381-00-0000-802-11-review-DMLT_answers20131113.pdf

Attachment: 8023-DMLT-SG-1311-Winkel-PAR-2013-11-13r3.4.pdf
Description: 8023-DMLT-SG-1311-Winkel-PAR-2013-11-13r3.4.pdf

Attachment: 8023-DMLT-SG-1311-Winkel-5C-v2 3.pdf
Description: 8023-DMLT-SG-1311-Winkel-5C-v2 3.pdf