| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
Removing some of the old messages in the thread because my response are being sent to the moderator. From: Pat Thaler
Dear Paul, I do not recall exactly when it was discussed before. It was during the time when Matt and I were vice-chairs because I remember him participating in the discussion. The rationale was that
the P&P is the highest IEEE 802 specific rules document and therefore are equivalent to our charter, constitution or bylaws and therefore not subject to suspension. One could also now make the argument that the P&P require approval by AudCom to go into effect.
A suspension of them by a vote of the EC wouldn’t have approval by the body that had to approve the P&P. If we can’t approve something by ourselves, I don’t think we can suspend it. (The discussion I recall probably happened before AudCom approval was required
because I remember the point being made when we were dividing the old P&P into a P&P and an OM that the division would allow us to vote to suspend OM rules).
The previous version of our P&P, i.e. the one from 2010, did not have the meeting notice requirement. Therefore when that was in effect the Chair’s Guideline 2.12 was valid. The Chair’s guidelines
are subsidiary to our P&P. Therefore, they cannot contradict or override a requirement in the P&P. The IEEE 802 P&P adopted on December 5, 2012 added the notice requirement that Geoff quoted below. When that was approved, Chair’s guideline 2.12 became invalid
because it conflicted with the P&P. Regards, Pat From: Paul Nikolich [mailto:paul.nikolich@att.net]
Pat, Do you recall when it was concluded the P&P were equivalent to bylaws and what the rationale was that led to that conclusion? This is an important point that I would like clarification on.
Regarding the approval threshold, I agree a 2/3 vote is appropriate. By the way, I forgot that we have in the Chair's guideline 2.12 IEEE 802 EC Interim telecon meetings the following text:
I would be willing to invoke the Chair's Guideline in this instance, but only if there are no objections. Regards, --Paul |