On Jan 2, 2018, at 10:35 AMPST, Adrian Stephens <adrian.p.stephens@ieee.org> wrote:Hello Geoff,
The ballot closed on Monday.
The comment resolution committee is scheduled to meet on Wednesday (tomorrow).
The working group will consider motions to request the EC to forward to RevCom during
the interim session Jan 14-19, probably Jan 17th. I will ask Paul for permission to run an EC
ballot with early close to meet the 26 Jan RevCom submission deadline. If necessary, I will
ask Paul for permission to pre-submit prior to reaching that approval. I don't anticipate any
issues with this project as it has proved remarkably free of controversy.
The comment complained that we had not provided a draft redline. While it is our custom,
and was our intention to provide a redline, this was overlooked in setting up the recirculation.
We did, however, meet the requirements of the SASB OM:
"5.4.3.4 Recirculation ballots
Changes may be made to the proposed standard in response to comments or for other reasons. All
substantive changes made since the last ballot of the proposed standard shall be identified and recirculated
to the Sponsor balloting group. ... " (my emphasis)
All substantive changes were identified in a comment resolution spreadsheet that accompanied the
ballot package.
I hope this answers your questions.
Good enough for me.
Thanks for your response.
Happy New Year,
Geoff
Best Regards, Adrian Stephens IEEE 802.11 Working Group Chair mailto: adrian.p.stephens@ieee.org Phone: +1 (971) 203-2032 Phone: +447342178905 Skype: adrian_stephensOn 02/01/2018 14:59, Geoff Thompson wrote:
Adrian-
What is the new comment?
What is the response from the consideration of that comment?
If a response to consideration of that comment has not been generated, what are the plans for doing so?
Happy New Year,
Geoff
On Jan 1, 2018, at 11:50 PMPST, Adrian Stephens <adrian.p.stephens@ieee.org> wrote:
Dear 802.11 participants and 802 EC,---------- This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector. This list is maintained by Listserv.
The second recirculation ballot of P802.11ak completed.
In September, 802.11 re-ordered 802.11aj, 802.11ak and 802.11aq in that order, so 802.11ak is dependent on 802.11aj.
802.11aj satisfied the terms of its November 802 EC approval, and is on the January NesCom telecon agenda.
This ballot resulted in a single non-MBS comment from an approve voter.
BALLOT OPEN DATE: 22-Dec-2017 BALLOT CLOSE DATE: 01-Jan-2018 TYPE: New DRAFT #: 6.0 BALLOTS RECEIVED: 3 VOTE CHANGES: 3 COMMENTS: 1 RESPONSE RATE
87 affirmative votes 3 total negative votes with comments 0 negative votes with new comments 1 negative votes without comments 0 abstention votes
91 votes received = 84% returned 0% abstention APPROVAL RATE
87 affirmative votes 3 negative votes with comments
90 votes = 96% affirmative -- Best Regards, Adrian Stephens IEEE 802.11 Working Group Chair mailto: adrian.p.stephens@ieee.org Phone: +1 (971) 203-2032 Phone: +447342178905 Skype: adrian_stephens