[802SEC] PAR comments for 802.15.4t and 802.15.4u
Bob
I have no comments on the 802.15.3d PAR.
My comments for the other 802.15 PARs are:
802.15.4t
PAR
5.2.b - The scope does not specify a target range for the resulting
standard. Is it 1 m, 1 km, 1 lightyear? Please specify a target
range with numerical distance target.
CSD
1.1.1 - Adding a new PHY mode will likley require defining new
managed objects (i.e., PIB entries) to control the use of the PHY.
Modify a) to say: "While no new managed objects are anticipated, any
managed objects that are required will be defined as part of the
project."
802.15.4u
PAR
5.2.b - The scope does not specify a target range or data rate for
the resulting standard. Is the range 1 m, 1 km, 1 lightyear? Is the
data rate 1 kb/s or 10 Gb/s? Please specify a target range with
numerical distance target and target data rates with numerical
values.
CSD
1.1.1 - Adding a new PHY mode will likley require defining new
managed objects (i.e., PIB entries) to control the use of the PHY.
Modify a) to say: "While no new managed objects are anticipated, any
managed objects that are required will be defined as part of the
project."
Editorial: 1.2.1 a) and 1.2.3, use a space between 867 and MHz.
James Gilb
----------
This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector. This list is maintained by Listserv.