[802SEC] Clause 13 report for IEEE P802.3 (IEEE 802.3bh) Ethernet Maintenance #10 (Revision) to RevCom

["Law, David" <dlaw@HP.COM>]

Dear EC members,

At the July 2012 IEEE 802 Plenary meeting conditional approval was granted to forward IEEE P802.3 (IEEE 802.3bh) Ethernet Maintenance #10 (Revision) to RevCom. Details are provided in the attached report but in summary the response to the Clause 13 'Procedure for Conditional Approval to Forward a Draft Standard' items are as follows:

a) The recirculation occurred essentially in accordance
   with the plan presented.

b) The approval rate after resolution of the ballot is 
   greater than 75% and there were no new negative
   DISAPPROVES votes.

c) No technical changes have been made.

d) There were no new valid DISAPPROVE comments. An
   editorial required (ER) comment, not associated
   with a vote, was received from Editorial Coordination
   that reads 'This draft meets all editorial requirements'.

e) Two editorial required (ER) comments, two technical required
   (TR) and one General Required (GR) comments were received
   from an existing disapprove voter. 

   The Working Group chair determines the two ER comments as out
   of scope as they are against unchanged text, and the two TR
   comments and the one GR comments as being a restatement of
   an already rejected, rebutted and recirculated comment.

   For full details please see the attached comment database
   report.

Based on the above IEEE P802.3 (IEEE 802.3bh) will remain on the August RevCom agenda.

Best regards,
  David Law


----------
This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector.  This list is maintained by Listserv.

Attachment: IEEE802d3bh_clause_13_report.pdf
Description: IEEE802d3bh_clause_13_report.pdf

Attachment: P802d3_802d3_bh_r3_all_clause.pdf
Description: P802d3_802d3_bh_r3_all_clause.pdf