[802SEC] RE: [802SEC] EC electronic ballot on 802.22 press release (CLEAN version of document attached)
I sent the "track changes" version with the ballot so Roger and others could
see the changes from the version I posted with the original motion to
address Roger's helpful comments.
Attached is a "CLEAN" version (changes accepted) for those who prefer that.
(If one ignores the "track changes" showing the delta, they are identical.)
Since there will still be at least 10 days prior to the close of the ballot,
the previously noted closing time stands.
Regards,
Carl
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Roger B. Marks [mailto:r.b.marks@ieee.org]
> Sent: Thursday, March 30, 2006 3:02 PM
> To: wk3c@WK3C.COM
> Cc: stds-802-sec@ieee.org
> Subject: Re: [802SEC] EC electronic ballot on 802.22 press release
>
> Carl,
>
> If this were a recirc, I think it would be fine
> to send around a marked-up copy for review.
> However, in a new ballot, I think that the voters
> need to see a clean copy. Otherwise, I think you
> introduce unnecessary ambiguity add make the task
> of the voters unnecessarily complicated.
>
> Since you had already distributed a preview copy,
> I understand why you wanted to show markups. But,
> on principle, I think it is important that the
> ballot group members see a clean copy and know
> that this is the document they are voting to
> approve.
>
> Regards,
>
> Roger
>
>
> At 02:38 PM -0500 06/03/30, Carl R. Stevenson wrote:
> >Dear all,
> >
> >Paul has delegated it to me to conduct an EC electronic ballot on the
> >approval of the attached proposed 802.22 press release.
> >
> >In response to my earlier motion, I received some editorial
> comments from
> >Roger, which I appreciate and think add clarity, so I'm
> attaching a "r1"
> >version of the document which shows the changes that Roger
> suggested and I
> >find acceptable and THAT is the version that's the subject
> of this ballot.
> >
> >MOVE: That the EC approve the release of the attached press
> release on
> >802.22's progress (document PR_P02_22V4r1.doc).
> >Moved: Stevenson
> >Second: Shellhammer (Dr. Shellhammer has read the document -
> including the
> >editorial changes in "r1" - and agreed to 2nd my motion.)
> >
> >INFORMATIONAL - this DRAFT press release accurately states
> the current
> >status of 802.22 and points to the significant progress that
> 802.22 has
> >achieved by going from 10 initial proposals to a single
> merged proposal
> >(baseline) between November 2005 and March 2006. I think
> that, coupled with
> >Stuart's press release indicating similar movement towards
> consensus in one
> >of his TGs, it is important to give 802 some positive press
> rather than
> >simply
> >allowing them to feed on the occasional contentious deadlock as has,
> >unfortunately, been the case in the past.
> >(Karen McCabe had reviewed, edited, and approved the
> previously circulated
> >version (prior to Roger's editorial suggestions), so I am
> simultaneously
> >cc'ing the "r1" version attached to her for her review and
> approval and do
> >not anticipate that she will have any problems with the
> editorial changes
> >that Roger suggested and I've accepted. However, regardless
> of the EC vote
> >on this ballot, I will not ask Karen to release the press
> release in the
> >event she does have problems with the changes. I will also
> inform the EC
> >ASAP if she indicates to me that she *does* have any
> problems with the
> >changes and I will re-start the clock on the ballot on a
> "r2" version that
> >addresses any unanticipated issues she may have with the
> revised version.)
> >
> >This ("10 day")EC e-mail ballot will close at 11:59 pm EST
> on April 9th,
> >2006, or when all EC members have voted, whichever comes first.
> >
> >Your prompt attention to voting will be appreciated.
> >
> >Regards,
> >Carl
> >
> >
> >
> >----------
> >This email is sent from the 802 Executive
> >Committee email reflector. This list is
> >maintained by Listserv.
> >
> >Attachment converted: Little Al:PR_P802 22V4_r1.doc
> (WDBN/<IC>) (000B3485)
>
>
>
----------
This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector. This list is maintained by Listserv.
PR_P802 22V4_r1_CLEAN.doc