Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

[802SEC] +++EC Motion+++ P802.3ah conditional approval+++ FINAL RESULT: PASS



Dear SEC members,

This ballot was scheduled to close NOON EST Monday December 1, 2003, however I held the ballot open through 3PM since I received 2 votes a couple hours past NOON. 
 
The final ballot tally as of 7PM EST Dec 2, 2003 is 10 APP, 1 DIS, 0 ABS, 2 DNV.  The motion passed.
Regards,

 --Paul Nikolich


 Vote categories:         DIS    DNV    APP    ABS
 -----------------------------------------------
 01 Geoff Thompson        DIS
 02 Mat Sherman                          APP
 03 Buzz Rigsbee                         APP
 04 Bob O'Hara                           APP
 05 Bill Quackenbush                     APP*
 06 Tony Jeffree                         APP
 07 Bob Grow                             APP
 08 Stuart Kerry                 DNV
 09 Bob Heile                    DNV
 10 Roger Marks                          APP*
 11 Mike Takefman                        APP
 12 Carl Stevenson                       APP
 13 Jerry Upton                          APP
 
                    total: -01-  -02-    -10-  -00-
 
*votes received by 3PM EST Dec 01
----- Original Message -----
To: IEEE802
Sent: Friday, November 21, 2003 11:56 AM
Subject: [802SEC] +++EC Motion+++ P802.3ah conditional approval

Dear SEC members,

This is a 10 day SEC email ballot to make a determination by EC motion to conditionally approve P802.3ah to begin Sponsor Ballot.
 

Motion

 

The LMSC executive committee grants conditional approval per Procedure 10, for P802.3ah sponsor ballot pending successful completion of the working group ballot process.

Moved by Bob Grow
Seconded by Tony Jeffree


The email ballot opens on Friday Nov 21 NOON EST and Monday Dec 1 NOON EST.

Please direct your responses to the EC reflector with a CC directly to me
(
p.nikolich@ieee.org).

Regards,

- Paul Nikolich

Chairman, IEEE 802 LMSC

 
 
Colleagues:

 

During the closing EC meeting, consideration of conditional approval for P802.3ah progressing to sponsor ballot was deferred for email consideration. 

 

  • The working group vote for conditional approval passed Y: 57, N: 2, A: 17 as shown in the attachment.
  • This EC vote is being conducted in parallel with the second working group recirculation ballot.  This timing will allow a sponsor ballot to be conducted prior to the Vancouver interim meeting if the recirculation ballot results satisfy Procedure 10 of the LMSC P&P.  There is insufficient time for conduct of a working group ballot, EC ballot and sponsor ballot in serial prior to the Vancouver meeting.
  • If the requirements of Procedure 10 are met, the sponsor ballot will open very quickly after close of the working group recirculation.
  • The initial P802.3ah/D2.0 working group ballot closed 3 Sep 2003 and the first WG recirculation ballot on P802.3ah/D2.1 closed 3 Nov 2003.  Complete comment databases from these two ballots are available at: http://www.ieee802.org/3/efm/public/comments/.
  • The ballot results are in the attached report.
  • Unresolved (unsatisfied) negative comments from D2.0 were included in  the D2.1 recirculation.
  • Unresolved (unsatisfied) negative comments from both D2.1 and D2.0 are included in the D2.2 recirculation.
  • If you want access to the drafts, please contact Howard or me for the username and password.

 

 

Motion

 

The LMSC executive committee grants conditional approval per Procedure 10, for P802.3ah sponsor ballot pending successful completion of the working group ballot process.