[802SEC] +++ WITHDRAWN: SEC Ballot: Forward IEEE 802.15.1 to Sponsor Ballot
Based on comments and discussions with Bob O'Hara, Vic Hayes, Roger Marks,
Bob Heile and Ian Gifford, this ballot is being withdrawn. There were
several discussions last week to better clarify the use of "must" and
"shalls" and a plan is now in place to update the draft and go through
another recirculation of the WG. Thanks to Bob O'Hara, Vic Hayes and Roger
Marks for providing detailed comments.
PASS:
Bob Grow -
Bob O'Hara-
Paul Nikolich -
Buzz Rigsbee -
Vic Hayes - Do Not Approve
Tony Jeffree -
Geoff Thompson -
Bob Love -
Stuart Kerry - Approve
Bob Heile - Approve
Roger Marks - Do Not Approve
Mike Takefman -
Jim Carlo - Chair
RESEND TO CLARIFY WHAT ACTION WE ARE TAKING. SORRY FOR DUPLICATION. I HAVE
ALSO ADDED POINTERS TO DRAFTS, REMAINING COMMENTS, BALLOT RESOLUTION PER VIC
HAYES REQUEST.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
SEC OFFICIAL EMAIL BALLOT 802.0/8May2001
Issue Date: 8May2001 Closing Date: 19May2001
Moved By: Bob Heile Seconded By: Stuart Kerry
Move: Approve Forwarding to Sponsor Ballot: 802.15.1 (Draft Standard for
Part 15.1: Wireless Medium Access Control (MAC) and Physical Layer (PHY)
specifications for Wireless Personal Area Networks(TM))
Notes:
1) During the Recirculation Ballot, one additional No voter made eight
comments, these comments were resolved without Technical Changes to the
draft through discussions with the WG Ballot Resolution Group, and the No
voter has changed his vote to an approve. The original NO voter continued to
vote NO with additional NO comments. Because of the additional No vote
received (even though resolved), a new SEC motion is required for approval
to move to Sponsor Ballot.
2) During the IEEE 802 Plenary HH SEC Meeting on 15Mar01 the following
motion was approved:
"Move that the ExCom forward IEEE Draft 802.15.1/D1.0 to Sponsor ballot,
based on a successful completion of a WG re-circulation ballot. Conditional
approval to expire at the beginning of the Portland Plenary Meeting"
3) The final ballot count is:
74 Working Group Voting Members
56 Voting Approve
1 Voting Do Not Approve (Disapprove comments circulated during last
recirculation ballot)
1 Abstain
Jim Carlo (j.carlo@ieee.org) Cellular:1-214-693-1776
Voice&Fax:1-214-853-5274
TI Fellow, Networking Standards at Texas Instruments
Vice Chair, IEEE-SA Standards Board
Chair, IEEE802 LAN/MAN Standards Committee